I have read mixed things in reviews on various reseller websites but I wanted to take this opportunity to pitch in one of my opinions. When it comes to purchasing ATI video cards the brand I tend to trust the most is Sapphire. I’ve read things about cards being DOA and running loud or hot, but I’ve simply never had that experience with any of their products.
Every Sapphire product I’ve owned has always been of the utmost craftsmanship. They are solid cards, they look attractive (literally as some of them have attractive females on their heat sinks), and they’ve been solidly reliable. I’ve yet to have one be arrive dead, or even fail on me. I’m on my second high-end Sapphire card and am planning to purchase a third. I just can’t think of another brand that has impressed me more.
On the other side of things, here are a few brands that I have had bad experiences with. For one, ATI brand ATI cards as found at Best Buy or ordered from ATI directly. My experience came from one purchased from Best Buy. I had an X1600 that after only a year failed out of the blue. There was no explanation for the failure and fortunately for me, Best Buy replaced it for me.
Another was HIS. Granted the HIS product I had ordered was listed as open box, the card was seemingly over designed. It was large, filled with capacitors, and worked for about 5 minutes, just long enough for me to get the drivers loaded, and then it died, never allowing a successful POST after. Since then I have avoided HIS like the plague.
Finally, and this is not a manufacturer of ATI cards, I’ve had a recent rash of EVGA failures at work. EVGA manufactures a video card model specifically for my company. This card is based on the Geforce 7300 chipset but is doctored up for video input capabilities. All of a sudden in the last few months I’ve had several inwhich after light to normal operation (no gaming or any kind of strenuous workload), three of the main capacitors on the card blow out. After this happens the system will continue to POST and will even get as far as the Windows XP splash screen. After the loading indicator finishes and the splash screen disappears as if it were loading the Windows Environment, it just stops sending signal to the monitor. The computer will even boot into safe mode and run in that environment normally. After experimenting with uninstalling the drivers, getting into Windows standard, and reinstalling the drivers, the problem persists. Finally on a whim I cracked one of the cases and took a look at the card and discovered the blown caps. Now as soon as I get a call describing these circumstances I know exactly what to do (IE replace the card) and I can have it fixed in 10 minutes. This has occurred with both the 7300’s we sell and the older 5200’s that we have in some of our older machines that are being supported. AGP or PCI-E, it makes no difference. So just a word of warning against EVGA.

Isn’t Windows XP great? Not that I am trying to say anything against Windows Vista. Windows Vista is a great new product with a lot of cool features. Well, if you buy the right version anyway. Windows XP also requires that you have the professional edition for it to be fully functional, but lets assume that you know this already.